Project Overview
This course project aims to help undergraduate and graduate students understand the basic workflow of academic conferences:
- Paper Submission: Learn how to prepare and submit academic papers
- Assignment Mechanism: Understand how papers are assigned to reviewers
- Peer Review: Experience the basic peer review process
Timeline
| Week 1-2 | Paper Preparation - Select research topic and write initial draft |
| Week 3 | Paper Submission - Submit complete paper through the system |
| Week 4-5 | Peer Review - Review assigned papers from other students |
| Week 6 | Feedback & Revision - Revise paper based on review comments |
Submission Requirements
Required LaTeX Template
ACM Conference Template (REQUIRED)
ACM SIGCONF proceedings format - mandatory for all submissions
Download ACM Template • Use the "sigconf" document classFormat Specifications
- Document Format: PDF file compiled from LaTeX source
- Template: ACM SIGCONF template (mandatory)
- Document Class: \documentclass[sigconf]{acmart}
- Paper Length: 4-6 pages (including references)
- Font: As specified in ACM template (typically 9pt)
- Column Layout: Two-column format (ACM style)
Content Requirements
- Language: English only
- Abstract: 150-250 words
- Keywords: 3-5 keywords
- References: Minimum 15 peer-reviewed sources
- Citation Style: ACM format (as per template)
- Figures/Tables: Must be properly captioned and referenced
Submission Details
- File Naming: StudentID_LastName_PaperTitle.pdf
- LaTeX Source: Submit both PDF and .tex files (zipped)
- Submission Method: Course management system
- File Size Limit: Maximum 10MB
Important: Only papers using the ACM SIGCONF template will be accepted. Papers submitted with other templates (IEEE, etc.) will be automatically rejected. Ensure your document compiles without errors using the ACM template.
Peer Review
Review Process
- Each student will be assigned 2-3 papers to review
- Use the provided review form for scoring
- Provide constructive feedback
- Complete reviews within the specified timeframe
Review Criteria
- Originality - Novelty and creativity of research content
- Methodology - Scientific rigor and appropriateness of research methods
- Writing Quality - Paper structure, language expression, and logical flow
- Literature Review - Completeness and accuracy of related work
Guidelines
Academic Integrity
All submitted work must be original. Plagiarism, ghostwriting, or other forms of academic misconduct are strictly prohibited.
- Use proper citations for all sources and ideas that are not your own
- Paraphrasing without citation is considered plagiarism
- Collaboration on individual assignments is not permitted
- AI-generated content must be clearly disclosed and properly attributed
- Violations will result in course failure and academic disciplinary action
Paper Writing Guidelines
Structure Requirements
- Title: Concise and descriptive (maximum 15 words)
- Abstract: Self-contained summary including problem, method, and key findings
- Introduction: Clear problem statement and research contributions
- Related Work: Comprehensive literature review with critical analysis
- Methodology: Detailed description of approach and experimental setup
- Results: Clear presentation of findings with appropriate visualizations
- Discussion: Interpretation of results and limitations
- Conclusion: Summary of contributions and future work
Writing Quality Standards
- Use clear, concise, and formal academic language
- Avoid first-person pronouns (I, we) in formal sections
- Ensure logical flow between paragraphs and sections
- Use active voice when possible
- Proofread for grammar, spelling, and punctuation errors
- Define technical terms and acronyms on first use
Research and Citation Guidelines
- Source Quality: Use peer-reviewed journals and conference papers primarily
- Currency: At least 70% of references should be from the last 5 years
- Diversity: Include international and diverse perspectives
- Citation Format: Follow ACM reference style consistently
- In-text Citations: Use proper ACM citation format [1], [2], etc.
- Avoid: Wikipedia, blogs, and non-academic websites as primary sources
Review Ethics and Process
Reviewer Responsibilities
- Maintain confidentiality of all reviewed materials
- Provide constructive, specific, and actionable feedback
- Focus on content quality, not personal preferences
- Complete reviews within the specified deadline
- Declare any conflicts of interest
- Use professional and respectful language
Review Criteria Details
- Technical Quality (30%): Soundness of methodology and analysis
- Novelty (25%): Originality and significance of contribution
- Clarity (25%): Writing quality and presentation
- Relevance (20%): Importance to the field and conference scope
Submission and Deadline Policies
- Late Submissions: 10% penalty per day late (maximum 3 days)
- Format Violations: Papers will be returned without review
- Resubmissions: One revision allowed based on initial feedback
- File Corruption: Students responsible for ensuring file integrity
- System Issues: Contact TA immediately if technical problems occur
Grading Rubric
| Component | Weight | Criteria |
|---|---|---|
| Paper Quality | 60% | Technical content, writing, formatting |
| Peer Reviews | 25% | Quality and timeliness of reviews provided |
| Revision | 15% | Response to feedback and improvement |
Technical Support
For technical issues or questions, please contact:
- Email: sychau [at] ie.cuhk.edu.hk
- Office Hours: Monday to Friday 9:00-17:00
- LaTeX Help: Tuesday & Thursday 14:00-16:00 (Room TBA)
- Emergency Contact: Available 24/7 for system outages
Important Email Policy: All emails must include [CUHK IAC 2025] in
the subject line. Emails without this tag may be delayed or missed.
Example: [CUHK IAC 2025] Question about LaTeX template
Resources
- ACM Reference Format Guide
- LaTeX Tutorial (Overleaf)
- Google Scholar - For finding academic sources
- Grammarly - For grammar and style checking